| November 24, 1990 | Cast: Jeff Keller (u/s), Rebecca Luker, Kevin Gray
| August, 1992 | Cast: Mark Jacoby, LuAnn Aronson, Hugh Panaro,Paul Laureano, Jeff Keller, Patrice Pickering, Marilyn Caskey, Gary Rideout, Catherine Ulyssies
| January 12, 2005 | Cast: David Gaschen, Sandra Joseph, John Cudia, Jeff Keller, George Lee Andrews, Anne Runolfsson, Marilyn Caskey, Larry Wayne Morbitt, Heather McFadden
| July 9, 2005| Cast:Hugh Panaro (The Phantom), Julie Hanson (Christine), Tim Martin Gleason (Raoul), Janet Saia (Carlotta), Jeff Keller (Monsieur Firmin), George Lee Andrews (Monsieur André), Marilyn Caskey (Madame Giry), Larry Wayne Morbitt (Piangi), Kara Klein (Meg Giry) Notes: Julie Hanson's last performance
| October 3, 2005| Cast: Howard McGillin, Sandra Joseph, Tim Martin Gleason, George Lee Andrews, Tim Jerome, Anne Runolfsson, Marilyn Caskey, Larry Wayne Morbitt, Kara Klein
| March 9, 2011| Cast: Hugh Panaro (The Phantom), Sara Jean Ford (Christine), Sean MacLaughlin (Raoul), Liz McCartney (Carlotta), David Cryer (Monsieur Firmin), George Lee Andrews (Monsieur André), Nancy Hess (Madame Giry), Evan Harrington (Piangi), Heather McFadden (Meg Giry)
| September 27, 2012| Cast: Greg Mills (u/s The Phantom), Elizabeth Welch (u/s Christine Daaé), Kyle Barisich (Raoul)
| March 15, 2013 | Cast: Hugh Panaro (The Phantom of the Opera), Samantha Hill (alt. Christine Daaé), Kyle Barisich (Raoul)
| August 24, 2013 | Cast: Peter Jöback, Marni Raab, Kyle Barisich, Michele McConnell, Jim Weitzer, Tim Jerome, Ellen Harvey, Christian Sebek, Kara Klein Notes: Peter Joback, Kyle Barisich, and Jim Weitzer’s last shows
| March 3, 2014| Cast: Hugh Panaro, Elizabeth Welch (u/s), Jeremy Hays Notes:Act 1 was recorded from the left rear mezz, and act 2 was recorded from the right front row.
| December 13, 2014. Matinee| Cast:Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Mary Michael Patterson, Jeremy Hays, Ellen Harvey, Michele McConnell, Christian Sebek
| June 9, 2016| Cast: Laird Mackintosh (u/s), Rachel Eskenazi-Gold (alt), Jeremy Hays, Craig Bennett, Richard Poole (u/s), Michele McConnell, John Easterlin, Rebecca Eichenberger, Kara Klein
| March 10, 2018| Cast: Peter Jöback (Phantom), Kaley Ann Voorhees (alt. Christine), Rodney Ingram (Raoul)
| May 12, 2018| Cast: Ben Crawford (Phantom), Kaley Ann Voorhees (alt. Christine), Jay Armstrong Johnson (Raoul), Raquel Suarez Groen (Carlotta), Laird Mackintosh (Andre), Craig Bennett (Firmin), Maree Johnson (Madame Giry), Chris Georgetti (Piangi), Kara Klein (Meg)
| May 25, 2019| Cast: Ben Crawford (The Phantom), Eryn LeCroy (alt. Christine), Jay Armstrong Johnson (Raoul), Scott Mikita, Laird Mackintosh, Raquel Suarez Groen, Maree Johnson, Carlton Moe, Kelsey Connolly